When you check out at the store, there’s a little dish with a sign asking for excess pennies or inviting you to use a penny or two if you are short. Why not do the same with commas?
Commas are always a bit tricky. There are so many exceptions to rules that, it turns out, aren’t really hard and fast rules.
When it comes to dependent clauses, the exceptions are rarer than most people think. Just put one in if the dependent clause comes before its independent clause, and leave it out if it follows the independent clause.
I’m worried about the state of writing, because commas are running rampant.
The comma in this sentence needs to come out and go into the comma jar. Writers (and editors) can dip into the jar when they see this sentence:
Because commas are running rampant I’m worried about the state of writing.
If I corral my commas into one place, I can avoid tripping over them throughout my office. They tend to hang out with the feral paper clips.
I’ve got a bit of room next to my monitor. It’s a perfect place for my comma jar. Where will you put yours?
What about commas used in persons addressed (or as we have watered it down to–person being spoken to)? I was always taught the person’s name or the noun/person was “set off by commas”–one before, one after. My students consistently leave off the one before, writing, “Don’t worry Mrs. Longest, your students will eventually learn to use commas.” Does this matter? Is it important? Please advise as to your thoughts.
LikeLike
Yes, it should be “Don’t worry, Mrs. Longest, your students will eventually learn to use commas.” I try to explain that “scoopable” words need commas before and after.
I keep saying it; they keep leaving one or more out. 😭😝
LikeLiked by 1 person
That helps! That helps a lot to call them “scoopable.” I think this is a great way to explain, and I shall use it next Wed. when I go to class. TY!
LikeLike
Happy to help! In our never ending quest for good writing…
LikeLike
That’s a good way to look at commas: the candy jar at the counter.
LikeLiked by 1 person