Who Cares About Shakespeare?

“I don’t know why we have to read Shakespeare,” grumbled a student recently.

Why should we care what someone who’s been dead going on 400 years had to say? What possible relevance could his writing have in an ever-connected, electronic, modern world?

The reason the Bard has lasted half a millennium is because he was a master of exposing the desires and emotions that make us human: envy, greed, arrogance, love, miscommunication, and social status. These things never change.

What sets him apart from a glorified Elizabethan soap opera writer is the way he develops his characters and their interrelationships. His plays are multi-layered. He can evoke sympathy for some of his most evil characters like Iago. He can make us lose patience with the hero (Hamlet).  He can show how the responsibilities of power can change our relationship with our friends (Henry V).

Modern relevance? Shakespeare dealt with depression and mental health issues hundreds of years ago in plays like Hamlet and King Lear. 

However (and this is a big “however”), there are two main problems facing modern readers of Shakespeare’s work. These are what produce groans and complaints from students.

A Rose by Any Other Name

The first is vocabulary. Let’s face it; English has changed in 500 years – a lot! It’s hard enough keeping track of the changes in word meanings and slang from the last half century let alone the last half millennium. And Shakespeare loved throwing in double meanings his Elizabethan audiences would have known and appreciated.

When I want to read Shakespeare, I first have to remind myself of some of the nuances of the vocabulary. Yes, reading the footnotes can be annoying, but they help me “get it.”

When we read Romeo and Juliet in ninth grade, I had a teacher who was wise enough to realize that Shakespeare’s English was like Greek to us.  He also knew that, if he pointed out some of the racier double entendres, he could keep the attention of his teenage students.  I thought he was a little crazy, but he made the play more real for us.

Any writer knows meaning is vitally important for painting the right picture. English has so many words! Synonyms have shades of meaning that can make a masterpiece out of a cartoon.

With Shakespeare, those shades of meaning are faded and need to be restored for us to appreciate the full richness of his work.

The Play Is the Thing

The second major problem with teaching Shakespeare is that students read the plays. Folks, the Bard’s work was meant for the stage, not the page.

Unlike a novel, where the author sets the scene and describes what is going on, a play is written with off-stage direction and dialog. If we can’t see and hear the speakers, with vocal inflections and body language, it’s really tough to get a good feel for the characters. It’s almost like reading a bunch of statements.

It wasn’t until I took a Shakespeare class in college that I truly appreciated the difference. At the time, PBS was running a series of BBC-produced Shakespeare plays. My professor held play-watching parties at her house. It was fun, and we got to experience Shakespeare the way he wanted us to – by watching the actors.

The Wheel Is Come Full Circle

Too often we think of Shakespeare as some guy sitting in a room churning out plays teachers tell us are masterpieces. Shakespeare lived in a time of political turmoil, intrigue, social class struggles, racism, and religious persecution. He sometimes put things into his plays that could be seen as critical to the monarchy, and he often skirted disaster.

Shakespeare Uncovered is a great PBS series that explores some of Shakespeare’s plays, what they mean, and the setting in which they were written.

It is important to remember that Shakespeare was a real man, living in a real world, with real problems. He used his talent to hold up a mirror to the world to say, “This is what you are, and this is what you could be.”

So, yes, what Shakespeare wrote centuries ago is still very much relevant today.


2 thoughts on “Who Cares About Shakespeare?

  1. It’s not just the old style of writing – its also the uselessness of what you are reading.
    Who cares if the Capulets did this and the X did Y?
    Who cares if this scene represents some overarching problem in society?
    Who cares if the name “Benvolio” means goodness and he is an archetype for XYZ?
    How useless is it now that you know this?

    As a high-school student, my only two explanation for why an English teacher would care this much about motifs and iambic pentameter is that they are mentally ill or have been molested and then brainwashed by a previous English teacher into somehow liking it.

    Don’t get me started on the writing in F451………
    Who cares if their struggle represents trying to fill a sieve with sand (lots of hard work but yet still futile)
    The theme in that book doesn’t make sense to start with!
    The theme as taught and explained in my English class: Marginalized groups don’t like certain books? The government is so nice that it will eliminate that book! In fact, books are now so bad that they will criminalize any found reading or even possessing books! And since books are obviously the one thing people need to not be mindless content-consumers, the whole world has become a dystopia! One day, when someone breaks out of this circle of “ignorance” caused by not reading books, he discovers book-refugees that are even stranger than the other ignorant people!
    Why would
    Why is a book important enough to devote your life to memorize? Do other people need to hear it THAT much?
    Please don’t describe people’s appearances with paragraphs of analogies and similes and more adjectives than a damn dictionary (e.g. Clarisse’s intro)! Seriously!

    I came to this page because I was curious of how on Earth a person could invest so much money for college to have to get into student debt, all in order learn about this. Apparently people can find jobs and earn enough to get out of this debt by using the knowledge they learned in college, by mind-fapping on Shakespeare.


    • Well. That’s quite a diatribe! I’m a little unsure if you just hate Shakespeare or you hate books in general.
      What do you think is the best way for us to display and consider universal human themes? Or do you think that is a useless activity? What do you think are constructive activities (ways to avoid “mind-fapping”?) I really am curious and interested in your feedback.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s